Looking for a wheelchair for yourself or a loved one? Choosing between a powered or manual wheelchair is one of the most important decisions you can make.
Here, we’ll guide you through the pros and cons of each type to help you make an informed choice.
Understanding the Basics: Manual vs Electric
When looking for a wheelchair, you’ll find two primary categories: manual wheelchairs and electric wheelchairs.
Manual wheelchairs are more affordable, but are power wheelchairs worth it for the extra features?
Which wheelchair is best for indoors? What about outdoors?
Can I bring this type of wheelchair on a plane?
Both power and manual wheelchairs have their own distinct benefits and drawbacks, and there’s no one-size-fits-all choice.
First, let’s go over the basics of each wheelchair type.
Manual Wheelchairs
- Manual force: As the name suggests, manual wheelchairs require the user or a caregiver to exert physical effort to push the wheelchair forward. This can be an excellent option for users with significant upper body strength or a regular caregiver, but may limit mobility for other users.
- Lightweight and portable: Most manual wheelchairs are designed to be lightweight and foldable, making them easy to transport and store. This can be exceptionally beneficial for frequent travelers or those with limited storage space.
- Cost-effective and low maintenance: Manual wheelchairs are affordable and don’t have complicated electrical components, which translates to low maintenance costs over time.
Electric Wheelchairs
- Motorized: Electric wheelchairs, or “power wheelchairs”, are powered by a motor and controlled using a joystick (and occasionally other adaptive technologies). These wheelchairs are an excellent choice for anyone with limited strength.
- Promote independence: For users with limited upper body strength, using a manual wheelchair requires constant caregiver support. With an electric wheelchair, users can navigate independently without assistance from others.
- Better all-terrain use: Depending on the model, electric wheelchairs can easily switch between indoor and outdoor terrain. They provide a smoother ride across uneven ground and up inclines, compared to manual wheelchairs.
Due to the enhanced features and electrical components, electric wheelchairs have a higher price point than manual wheelchairs. They are also generally more bulky, making them more challenging to quickly transport or place in storage.
Key Factors to Consider
Mobility Level
Manual wheelchairs require upper body strength in order to operate– the user must reach and use strength to propel themselves forward. For users with limited mobility or who tire easily, an electric wheelchair may be a preferred solution.
Lifestyle
Do you frequently travel or does your lifestyle typically stay within your neighborhood? Generally speaking, manual wheelchairs are more lightweight than electric wheelchairs. For those who are constantly on-the-go or travel frequently via airplane, manual wheelchairs are much simpler to “pack and go”.
Electric wheelchairs come with batteries that need to be approved for airline travel, and are often heavier and bulkier than manual wheelchairs.
Environment
Consider the environment that you’ll be using the wheelchair in. Do you often travel on uneven ground or an incline? Using a powered wheelchair may be preferable and save your arms from unnecessary exhaustion.
For those who embark on long daily journeys frequently, using a manual wheelchair all day may be just plain tiring. An electric wheelchair gives your arms a break, allowing you to relax the entire ride.
Budget
Of course, personal budget restrictions are always an important factor. In general, manual wheelchairs are a much more affordable option with lower maintenance costs over time. Electric wheelchairs are more expensive, though do provide extra features and convenience that may justify the cost for you.
Top Manual & Electric Wheelchairs
Here are a few of our top recommended manual and electric wheelchairs, to give you an idea of each wheelchair type.
Manual Wheelchairs
By Medline
Price: $329
The Guardian Reclining Wheelchair is designed to make your mobility experience as relaxing as it is reliable. This wheelchair prioritizes your comfort with its reclining backrest (adjustable from 90° to 140°), elevating leg rests to improve circulation, and adjustable armrests for personalized support. Its sleek, ergonomic design ensures smooth navigation across various surfaces, while three width options guarantee a perfect fit for every user. Anti-tipper technology provides extra stability and support for users up to 300 lbs.
Electric Wheelchairs
By Pride
Price: $4,259
Want a more independent lifestyle? Look no further. The Jazzy Air® 2 Elevating Power Chair combines unmatched mobility, convenience, and comfort for users seeking independence. Its innovative power-elevating seat raises up to 12 inches in just 11 seconds, allowing seamless transitions between heights for activities like dining or face-to-face conversations. The chair’s adjustable armrests, headrest, and footplate ensure personalized comfort, and its 19.2-mile battery range supports all-day use. Designed for both functionality and style, the Jazzy Air® 2 redefines mobility with its advanced features and user-focused design.
By Whill
Price: $3,999
A staff favorite for a reason– the WHILL Model C2 Power Chair offers the perfect blend of power, portability, and advanced technology. With a top speed of 5 mph and a range of up to 10 miles on a single charge, it’s ideal for errands, travel, or everyday use. Smart features like Bluetooth control, remote driving via an app, and a joystick customizable for left or right-handed use set it apart. The chair disassembles in just four steps for effortless transport, fits users up to 300 lbs, and offers six stylish color options.
Whether you’re looking for a wheelchair for yourself, a loved one, or a care facility, Med Mart is here to help. Browse through our catalog of industry-leading electric and manual wheelchairs today!